In the realm of governance, the wisdom of Niccolò Machiavelli remains as pertinent today as it was in 1513 when he penned The Prince. “The first method for estimating the intelligence of a ruler is to look at the men he has around him,” he wrote in Chapter XXII. This timeless observation finds a striking parallel in the political and security landscape of Anambra State, Nigeria, where the proverbial fox has been entrusted with the guardianship of the chicken coop.
The metaphor is not new to contemporary geopolitics. In April 2006, when the Hamas-led government of the Palestinian National Authority appointed Jamal Abu Samhadana as director-general of the paramilitary “Executive Force” in Gaza, the international community reacted with alarm. Samhadana was no ordinary security official. He had spent the better part of 25 years in exile, endured 19 months as a detainee of the Palestinian Authority, and was reportedly second on Israel’s most-wanted list. Gideon Meir, then spokesperson for Israel’s Foreign Ministry, captured the absurdity of the appointment with a simple yet powerful analogy: it was, he said, like “allowing the fox to guard the chicken coop.”
Anambra State, located in the South-east of Nigeria, would seem an unlikely stage for a re-enactment of this cautionary tale. Yet, unlike the Palestinian narrative, the Anambra version involves a fox that cannot claim the moral cover of a cause. The story unfolds over a quarter of a century, rooted in a period of profound transition for Nigeria as a nation.
In 1999, Nigeria returned to elective governance after 15 years of uninterrupted military rule. The transition, while historic, unleashed a wave of security challenges across many states in the federation. Few states grappled with these challenges as intensely as Anambra. The state’s new civilian governor, Chinwoke Mbadinuju, inherited a volatile environment marked by rising criminality and public unrest. His response to this crisis would set the stage for one of the most controversial chapters in the state’s modern history.
In 2000, Governor Mbadinuju assented to the Anambra Vigilante Services (AVS) Law, a piece of legislation designed to formalize community-based security operations. On paper, the law aimed to empower local vigilantes to assist in maintaining law and order. In practice, however, it opened the door to a far more sinister arrangement. Into this newly created legal space, the governor invited the Bakassi Boys—a group that Human Rights Watch would later describe as embodying the “legitimization of murder and torture.”
The Bakassi Boys were not a conventional security force. Their methods were brutal, extrajudicial, and deeply entrenched in a culture of violence. According to the Nigeria Police Force, their standard practice involved “hacking suspected criminals with machetes and then setting their bodies ablaze.” They operated with complete impunity, accountable to no one and subject to no oversight. The group’s reputation for extreme violence preceded them, and their presence in Anambra created a chilling effect that extended far beyond the criminal underworld.
The fear instilled by the Bakassi Boys served a dual purpose. While it ostensibly curbed street-level crime, it also functioned as a tool of suppression, effectively silencing public criticism of the prevailing misgovernance. The atmosphere of terror was conducive to maintaining a lid on dissent, even as the state’s administrative machinery began to falter. From 2001 onward, public sector workers in Anambra faced routine non-payment of salaries, a situation that would have catastrophic consequences for the state’s workforce and its institutions.
The year 2002 marked a tipping point. Teachers in the state’s public schools, having endured months without pay, declared an indefinite industrial action that lasted the entire academic year. The strike brought the educational system to a standstill, leaving thousands of students without instruction and further destabilizing an already fragile social fabric. State civil servants followed suit, embarking on a prolonged strike that crippled government operations for many months. Even the judiciary was not spared; judicial staff downed tools, bringing the courts to a halt in one of the most litigious states in the country.
The impact of the judiciary strike resonated far beyond the corridors of power. Onitsha, the leading commercial hub in southern Nigeria and the state’s largest city, is home to the highest concentration of lawyers in Anambra. For these legal practitioners, the prolonged shutdown of the courts was not merely an administrative inconvenience; it was a direct assault on their livelihoods. Kitchen-table conversations across the city were dominated by the uncertainty of when—or if—the justice system would resume its functions.
The irony of the situation was palpable. A state that had invited a murderous gang to restore order found itself descending into administrative chaos. The Bakassi Boys, far from being a stabilizing force, had become a symbol of the state’s moral and institutional decay. Their presence did not address the root causes of insecurity; it merely masked them beneath a veneer of terror. The rule of law, already fragile, was further eroded by the very mechanisms designed to uphold it.
Machiavelli’s counsel to rulers was prescient: the quality of a leader is reflected in the company they keep. In Anambra, the decision to empower the Bakassi Boys spoke volumes about the priorities and judgment of those at the helm. It was a decision that prioritized short-term control over long-term stability, and it came at a tremendous cost to the state’s citizens, its institutions, and its reputation.
The story of Anambra’s flirtation with vigilante justice is a cautionary tale about the dangers of compromising principles in the name of expediency. It underscores the importance of accountable governance and the perils of delegating state authority to unaccountable actors. The fox may have been effective at keeping the chickens in line, but at what price? The chickens lived in fear, the coop fell into disrepair, and the trust that binds a community to its leaders was shattered.
In the years since, Anambra has continued to navigate the complex interplay between security, governance, and public trust. The legacy of the Bakassi Boys, however, remains a stark reminder of what happens when the guardians of order become the purveyors of chaos. As Machiavelli observed centuries ago, the true measure of a ruler lies not in the power they wield, but in the character of those they choose to surround themselves with. In Anambra, that measure was found wanting, and the consequences continue to reverberate through the state’s collective memory.