The Court of Appeal sitting in Kaduna has dismissed an appeal filed by former Kaduna State Governor Nasir El-Rufai challenging the refusal of a fresh bail application by the Kaduna State High Court. The appellate court’s decision, delivered in a unanimous judgment by a three-member panel, affirms the lower court’s ruling of June 10, 2026, which denied the former governor bail in the criminal proceedings brought against him by the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission.
Appellate Panel Unanimous in Dismissing Appeal
According to the Certified True Copy of the judgment, the three-member appellate panel held that El-Rufai failed to establish fresh facts or special circumstances sufficient to warrant interference with the lower court’s decision to deny him bail. The lead judgment, delivered by Justice Onyekachi Aja Otisi, affirmed the ruling of the Kaduna State High Court, which had refused the former governor’s second bail application.
El-Rufai, who governed Kaduna State from 2015 to 2023, is being prosecuted by the ICPC over alleged financial offences arising from his administration. The former governor has consistently denied wrongdoing and has challenged the circumstances surrounding his continued detention.
The Kaduna State High Court had earlier dismissed the bail application filed by the former governor and ordered an accelerated hearing in the matter. Dissatisfied with that decision, El-Rufai approached the appellate court seeking a reversal.
In its ruling, the appellate court held that the lower court acted within its judicial discretion in refusing bail, noting that the decision was properly based on the affidavit evidence presented by both parties. Justice Otisi stated unequivocally: “There is no merit in this appeal; it fails and is hereby dismissed. The ruling of the lower court delivered on 10/6/2026 is hereby affirmed.”
Prosecution Raises Concerns Over Public Remarks
The appellate court considered the prosecution’s argument that some of El-Rufai’s public remarks during a televised interview raised concerns about possible interference with the course of justice. The prosecution told the court that the former governor made public remarks about defending his political legacy against those seeking to criminalise him.
It also alleged that El-Rufai admitted during an Arise Television interview on April 26, 2026, to wiretapping the telephone line of the National Security Adviser. According to the judgment, El-Rufai acknowledged participating in the interview and noted that he was being tried in a separate case relating to the subject matter.
However, the appellate court stressed that its decision did not amount to a finding of guilt, noting that the former governor remained presumed innocent until proven guilty. “Now, without doubt, by unequivocal constitutional provisions, the appellant is presumed innocent until proven guilty,” Otisi stated. He added that the trial court’s evaluation of the affidavit evidence concerning the potential interference with justice did not constitute a pronouncement of guilt.
Court Rejects Flight Risk Argument
The court also considered El-Rufai’s argument that his voluntary return to custody after attending his late mother’s burial demonstrated that he was not a flight risk. The former governor had submitted that his release to attend the burial and subsequent return to custody constituted compelling grounds for granting bail.
However, the prosecution maintained that he was accompanied and closely monitored by security agents throughout the burial period. The appellate court noted that photographs allegedly showing El-Rufai attending the funeral prayers at the National Mosque in Abuja were referenced in his affidavit but were not attached to the application before the trial court.
Justice Otisi said the trial judge could not speculate on what the unattached photographs would have shown. “Courts are not allowed to act on speculations or conjecture to reach a decision, more so in our criminal jurisprudence,” he said.
The court consequently upheld the lower court’s conclusion that El-Rufai had not established that his return to custody was entirely voluntary or that the circumstances justified a different bail decision.
Accelerated Hearing Order Upheld
The appellate court also upheld the order for an accelerated hearing of the criminal trial, with proceedings to be conducted on a day-to-day basis as far as practicable while El-Rufai remained in the custody of the ICPC. The court noted that no evidence had been presented to show that the prosecution had failed to pursue the case diligently.
Justice Otisi added that El-Rufai could return to the trial court to seek further consideration of his bail application if the prosecution failed to prosecute the case diligently.
In a concurring judgment, Justice Abimbola Obaseki-Adejumo agreed that the former governor had not presented fresh and compelling facts to justify a different outcome. “Nothing had changed; therefore, I am unable to agree that a miscarriage of justice had occurred,” she held. Justice Lateef Ganiyu also concurred with the lead judgment, holding that the failure to attach documents relied upon in the bail application worked against the appellant’s case.
Background to the Proceedings
In March 2026, the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission took former Kaduna State Governor Nasir El-Rufai into custody following an investigation into alleged financial infractions and procurement irregularities during his tenure from 2015 to 2023. The case has proceeded through the Kaduna State High Court, which initially dismissed his bail application and ordered an accelerated hearing, before the matter reached the appellate court.
The Court of Appeal’s decision brings clarity to the immediate question of bail while leaving the substantive criminal trial to proceed before the lower court. The appellate panel’s emphasis on the presumption of innocence underscores that the ruling on bail does not constitute a determination of guilt, and the former governor retains the right to seek further consideration of his bail application should the prosecution fail to pursue the case diligently.
With the appellate court’s affirmation of the lower court’s ruling, the criminal proceedings against El-Rufai are set to continue on an accelerated basis, with the former governor remaining in the custody of the ICPC as the trial progresses.