Court of Appeal Clears Bukola Saraki in Kwara Defamation and Cyberbullying Case
The Court of Appeal sitting in Ilorin has dismissed the criminal defamation and cyberbullying suit filed by the Kwara State Government against former Senate President Bukola Saraki, ruling that the prosecution failed to establish any criminal offence against him.
In a judgment delivered on Tuesday, the appellate court held that Saraki’s comments questioning Governor AbdulRahman AbdulRazaq’s educational qualifications and judgment were not capable of inciting violence or causing a breakdown of law and order anywhere in the state. Justice Ridwan Abdullahi read the judgment on behalf of the panel, which also comprised Justices Gabriel Omoniyi Kolawole and Abdu Dogo.
Prosecution Evidence Falls Short, Court Rules
The court took issue with the evidence presented by the prosecution, noting that the testimony of its witnesses did not establish that Saraki’s remarks had resulted in any breach of the peace. According to the court, the evidence merely showed that the witnesses were dissatisfied with the former Senate president’s statement rather than demonstrating that it had triggered violence or threatened public order.
Justice Abdullahi stated that nothing in the comment complained of by Governor AbdulRazaq was capable of inciting violence in any part of Kwara State or moving anyone to resort to a breakdown of law and order.
The court further held that the laws cited in the charge, including the Administration of Criminal Justice Act, the Kwara State Penal Code Law, and the relevant cybercrime and cyberbullying provisions, were not enacted to shield individuals from statements they found offensive or uncomfortable. The judge emphasised that the purpose of criminal legislation is not to provide a means of prosecuting people simply because their comments displeased those being criticised.
Limits of Prosecutorial Powers Highlighted
The appellate court also addressed the scope of prosecutorial authority, stressing that while the Attorneys-General of the federation and states have broad powers to institute criminal proceedings, those powers must be exercised within the confines of the law. The court warned that such authority cannot be deployed in a manner that prejudices or oppresses an individual or violates the fundamental human rights of citizens.
Consequently, the court ordered that the case instituted against Saraki at the Kwara State High Court could not be sustained, holding that the charge failed to disclose an offence or establish the statutory ingredients required to substantiate the allegations against him.
Background of the Case
The case stemmed from a statement Saraki published on social media and in a newspaper on April 17, 2026, in which he alleged that Governor AbdulRazaq had not completed secondary school and that his level of education was affecting his judgment. The state government subsequently accused the former Senate president of criminal defamation and cyberbullying, arguing that the publication was capable of causing a breakdown of public peace.
Saraki challenged the proceedings, maintaining that his comments fell within the exercise of his right to freedom of expression and constituted a response to issues of public interest.
Saraki Hails Judgment as Defence of Dissent
Reacting to the appellate court’s decision, Saraki said the judgment had reaffirmed his belief that political power should not be used to suppress dissent. He stated that nobody, no matter how powerful, can successfully muffle the voice of dissent, particularly when those in government fail in their responsibility to the people.
The former Senate president expressed appreciation to the judiciary, saying he was grateful that the courts had continued to uphold justice and defend the truth. He also maintained that the ruling would not deter him from commenting on matters affecting the public, including questions surrounding the governor’s educational qualifications.
Saraki said he would not hesitate to restate his position if the need arose, adding that he would continue to speak whenever issues of public interest warranted his intervention.
Separate Offa Robbery Case Remains
The ruling concerns only the criminal defamation and cyberbullying case arising from Saraki’s comments about the governor’s educational background. It is separate from the 20-count case instituted by the state government against Saraki, former Governor Abdulfatah Ahmed, and two former aides over allegations relating to the 2018 Offa robbery.
Saraki and the Peoples Democratic Party have described the separate Offa robbery-related prosecution as politically motivated, while the state government and the All Progressives Congress have defended it as a lawful prosecution arising from allegations linked to the robbery.