Share This Post via WhatsApp

A Federal High Court sitting in Lagos has nullified the publication of Ibrahim Lukman as the candidate of the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC) for the Oshodi/Isolo Federal Constituency I seat in the 2027 general election, ordering the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to replace his name with that of the party’s recognised primary winner, Olumuyiwa Owadara.

In a judgment delivered on October 20, Justice Akintayo Aluko held that Lukman did not take part in the party’s primary election and that INEC acted in breach of the Electoral Act 2026 by publishing his name despite having monitored the May 29 primary at which Owadara emerged victorious. The court consequently directed the commission to publish Owadara’s name and particulars as the party’s lawful candidate.

The Court’s Orders

Justice Aluko set aside INEC’s August 1 publication of Lukman as the NDC’s candidate for the constituency and ordered the commission to immediately publish the name and particulars of Owadara. The court also awarded costs of N1 million against INEC and Lukman.

The judgment rested heavily on INEC’s own monitoring report, which the court said established that Owadara “scored the highest number of lawful votes cast” at the primary. The NDC informed the court that it conducted no other primary for the constituency and that Lukman did not participate in the exercise. Despite this, INEC published Lukman’s name and particulars as the party’s candidate, leaving Owadara off the list.

Owadara told the court that he had completed his nomination forms and submitted them to the commission. INEC, for its part, argued that it merely published the names uploaded to its platform by political parties, including the NDC. Justice Aluko rejected that explanation, holding that it was not supported by credible evidence.

“I am of the view that the evidence of the 1st Defendant that the names it published are the names uploaded on its platform by political parties including the 2nd Defendant is not supported or corroborated by any credible evidence,” the judge held.

Party Denies Sponsoring Lukman

The court further recorded that the NDC denied sending Lukman’s name to INEC and accused the commission of imposing him on the party, a power it said the electoral umpire does not possess under the law. Justice Aluko held that because Lukman had not participated in the primary, INEC had no lawful basis to publish him as the party’s candidate.

“The commission has no lawful basis or justification to publish the name and particulars of the 3rd Defendant as the candidate of the 2nd Defendant for the said election,” the judge said.

He ruled that the publication amounted to “non-compliance with and brutal violation of” Sections 29(1), 32(1) and 84(1) of the Electoral Act 2026, which govern the submission of candidates emerging from valid primaries and the commission’s monitoring of party primaries.

The court also found no credible evidence that the NDC had invoked the statutory process for changing its candidate under Section 33 of the Act or conducted another primary.

“There is no credible evidence before the court to suggest that the 2nd Defendant as a political party took steps to change its candidate in line with the provision of section 33 of the Electoral Act or that another primary election was held by the 2nd Defendant,” Justice Aluko held.

Primary Conducted in Line With the Law

Justice Aluko concluded that Owadara had established his case with credible evidence, adding that the primary was conducted in accordance with the party’s guidelines and constitution as well as the Electoral Act.

“It is my humble but firm conviction that the plaintiff has established by credible evidence that the primary election was conducted in consonance with the guidelines, constitution of the 2nd defendant and the Electoral Act and that the plaintiff emerged the winner,” he said.

The judge added that INEC’s publication of Lukman’s name “is in violent breach of the Guidelines, the Constitution of the 2nd Defendant and the relevant provisions of the Electoral Act.”

In reaching his decision, Justice Aluko relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Igboke v. Chukwu (2023), which set aside INEC’s publication of a candidate who had not won the relevant party primary.

Service Challenge Dismissed

Lukman had challenged the court’s jurisdiction, asking that the suit be struck out on the grounds that he was not properly served with the originating summons. He claimed he was in London when service was purportedly effected and denied that the WhatsApp number and email address used belonged to him.

The court dismissed the objection, noting that it had authorised substituted service on August 19 after the bailiff failed to serve Lukman personally. The bailiff’s affidavit stated that the processes were subsequently served through WhatsApp on August 24.

Justice Aluko found that the number used for service was the same one Lukman supplied to INEC in his Form EC9, an affidavit of personal particulars sworn to on June 27 and tendered by Owadara.

“There is, however, credible evidence before the court to demonstrate that the 3rd Defendant is not truthful after all,” the judge said.

The court also considered WhatsApp exchanges between the lawyers to Owadara and Lukman, which it said showed that court processes were exchanged on August 27, 28 and 31. Citing the Supreme Court’s decision in Saleh v. Abah, the judge held that service on a party’s counsel who did not deny receiving the processes was valid.

The judge further noted that Lukman filed no counter-affidavit or defence to the originating summons and had therefore “failed to controvert or deny the claims and case of the Plaintiff.”

Counsel Hails Judgment as Victory for Democracy

Owadara’s legal team was led by Festus Ogun, Managing Partner of FOLEGAL, with Tofunmi Adetunji and Omobola Olayanju. Ogun said the judgment had affirmed the judiciary’s role in upholding the law.

“We are most relieved that the court has demonstrated once again that it remains an impartial institution of trust which dispenses justice without fear or favour,” he said.

He said the team had been confident in its legal argument against the publication of a candidate who did not participate in the recognised primary.

“The last-minute announcement of an individual who never participated in the recognised primary election as a candidate is a stain on the process and institutions manning the election and a grave injustice against the legitimate winner, which should not be allowed to stand,” Ogun said.

“We are happy the court agreed with us and ordered INEC to substitute the name for our client. This is a victory for democracy.”

Submissions by the Parties

The NDC, through its counsel, Ikechukwu Onodi, argued that INEC lacked the power to substitute a validly nominated candidate, maintaining that substitution was an internal party matter subject to statutory conditions. He also argued that the commission’s role in primaries was limited to monitoring the exercise and seeking clarification where necessary.

INEC’s counsel, Segun Bello, argued that determining whom a political party sponsors was not the commission’s responsibility and that INEC was required to remain neutral.

On October 23, FOLEGAL wrote to the INEC National Chairman, enclosing a certified true copy of the judgment and requesting immediate compliance with the orders.

“We respectfully anticipate your earnest compliance with the said Orders of the Court,” the letter signed by Ogun stated.

Key Takeaways

The case underscores the legal limits of INEC’s role in the candidate nomination process. While the commission has consistently maintained that it only publishes names uploaded by political parties, the court found that position unsupported where the evidence showed a candidate had not emerged from a monitored primary. The ruling reinforces the principle that only candidates who participate in and win valid party primaries can be lawfully published as party standard-bearers.

The judgment also highlights the importance of INEC’s monitoring reports as evidence in pre-election disputes. In this instance, the commission’s own record of the May 29 primary proved decisive in establishing that Owadara, not Lukman, won the contest.

With the court ordering the substitution of names and the plaintiff’s legal team pressing for compliance, attention now shifts to INEC to see whether it will promptly update its records in line with the judgment ahead of the 2027 general election.

Rate This Post / Article

Disclaimer: Every member is solely responsible for the content they publish on Nigerpress. Opinions, information, and statements expressed are not endorsed by Nigerpress.

Leave a Reply