The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) presented a compact disc in open court on Wednesday containing an alleged voice note of former Minister of Aviation, Hadi Sirika. In the recording, Sirika is purportedly heard directing the award of a consultancy contract to a company linked to one of his associates. The audio was played before Justice Sylvanus Oriji of the Federal Capital Territory High Court in Abuja during the testimony of the EFCC’s 12th prosecution witness, Christopher Odofin, an investigator with the anti-graft agency.
According to court proceedings, the recording was allegedly made while Sirika was in Spain. In the audio, the former minister is heard instructing the then Permanent Secretary of the Ministry of Aviation, Enitan Abel, to facilitate the award of a consultancy contract to Tianaero Nigeria Limited. “Do the right thing. Generate the necessary contract and give his company. We can pay for his services,” the voice in the recording, allegedly identified as Sirika’s, stated.
The EFCC has charged Sirika alongside his daughter, Fatima; his son-in-law, Hamma Sule; and Al-Buraq Global Investment Limited on an amended six-count charge bordering on alleged abuse of office and contract fraud. The anti-graft agency alleges that Sirika used his official position to confer an unfair advantage on Al-Buraq Global Investment Limited, a company reportedly linked to his daughter and son-in-law, in the award of a contract for the apron extension at Katsina Airport valued at approximately N1.4 billion.
Led in evidence by prosecution counsel Rotimi Jacobs, Odofin identified the voice in the recording as belonging to the former minister. The witness informed the court that Tianaero Nigeria Limited, the company mentioned in the voice note, belonged to Gabriel Tilmann, whom he described as a close associate of Sirika. In another portion of the recording played in court, the voice allegedly belonging to Sirika praised Tilmann’s capabilities and urged ministry officials to support him. “Whatever we can get, he’s quite resourceful and very energetic. So, he has what it takes. Mr Tilmann gets angry and irritated easily. He is comfortable with the ministry because of me,” the audio continued.
Court proceedings briefly stalled when counsel for Al-Buraq Global Investment Limited, Michael Numa, objected to the prosecution’s line of questioning. Justice Oriji, however, advised the defense to reserve its objections for cross-examination. Numa responded that the prosecution’s questions appeared designed to elicit prejudicial information, but the judge maintained that the trial should proceed, allowing the defense to challenge the evidence during cross-examination.
The EFCC’s case centers on allegations that Sirika, while serving as Minister of Aviation, abused his office by steering lucrative contracts to companies connected to his family and associates. The voice note, if authenticated, could serve as critical evidence linking the former minister directly to the alleged contract manipulation. The prosecution argues that the recording demonstrates Sirika’s active role in directing the award of a consultancy contract to Tianaero Nigeria Limited, a company owned by his associate, Gabriel Tilmann.
During the hearing, Odofin, the EFCC investigator, provided detailed testimony about the chain of custody of the compact disc and the process by which the recording was obtained. He stated that the audio was recovered from electronic devices seized during the investigation and that forensic analysis confirmed its authenticity. The witness also noted that the voice in the recording matched known samples of Sirika’s speech patterns, though the defense is expected to challenge this identification during cross-examination.
The case has drawn significant public attention due to the high-profile nature of the accused and the substantial sums involved. The apron extension contract at Katsina Airport, valued at N1.4 billion, is one of several contracts under scrutiny. The EFCC alleges that Sirika used his influence to ensure that Al-Buraq Global Investment Limited, a company with ties to his daughter and son-in-law, received preferential treatment in the bidding process. The prosecution contends that this constituted a clear abuse of office and a violation of public procurement laws.
Justice Oriji has scheduled the next hearing for a date to be determined, during which the defense will have the opportunity to cross-examine Odofin and challenge the admissibility of the voice note. The defense is expected to argue that the recording was obtained illegally or that the voice identification is unreliable. Legal experts note that the outcome of this case could have significant implications for anti-corruption efforts in Nigeria, particularly regarding the use of digital evidence in high-profile prosecutions.
The EFCC’s decision to play the voice note in open court underscores the agency’s commitment to transparency in its prosecution of corruption cases. By presenting the evidence publicly, the commission aims to demonstrate the strength of its case while allowing the court to assess the credibility of the recording. The trial continues to unfold as both sides prepare for what is expected to be a lengthy legal battle.
In addition to the voice note, the prosecution has presented documentary evidence, including contract documents, financial records, and witness statements, to support its allegations. The EFCC has also called several other witnesses who have testified about the procurement process and the alleged irregularities in the award of the Katsina Airport contract. The defense, meanwhile, has maintained Sirika’s innocence, arguing that the charges are politically motivated and that the evidence presented so far is circumstantial.
The case has also raised questions about the role of family members in public procurement. Sirika’s daughter, Fatima, and son-in-law, Hamma Sule, are accused of being beneficiaries of the alleged fraud through their association with Al-Buraq Global Investment Limited. The EFCC alleges that the company was used as a vehicle to siphon public funds, with Sirika leveraging his position to ensure that the company received contracts without competitive bidding.
As the trial progresses, the court will need to weigh the evidence presented by both sides. The voice note, if admitted as evidence, could be a pivotal piece of the prosecution’s case. However, the defense is likely to challenge its authenticity and the circumstances under which it was obtained. Legal analysts suggest that the case may ultimately hinge on the credibility of the recording and the testimony of the EFCC investigator.
The EFCC has reiterated its commitment to pursuing corruption cases regardless of the status of the accused. The agency’s spokesperson stated that the commission is confident in its evidence and expects a fair trial. Meanwhile, Sirika and his co-defendants remain on bail, with the court imposing strict conditions to ensure their appearance at subsequent hearings.
The trial is being closely monitored by civil society organizations and anti-corruption advocates, who see it as a test of Nigeria’s judicial system’s ability to hold public officials accountable. The outcome could set a precedent for how digital evidence is handled in corruption cases and whether voice recordings can be used to secure convictions. For now, the court continues to hear evidence, with the next session expected to focus on the defense’s objections to the voice note.