Three score and three years ago, a defining dispute erupted in the old Western Region of Nigeria over the scope and reach of constitutional conventions in determining or terminating the tenure of high-level political leadership. The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, which ultimately had to pronounce on the matter, described conventions in that case as “a body of understandings which no writer can formulate.” The aftermath of that decision took the country to the brink of ruin.
This year, the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) confronts its own moment of truth concerning how far conventions initially designed to accommodate national diversity in its leadership processes can be converted into ethno-tribal vetoes by entities that in fact are not part of its institutional or constitutional organs. The consequences for the association could be far reaching.
For context, the NBA elects a new set of leaders every even-numbered year. It has long been the assumption that “the NBA is too important to be left alone.” Elections into its leadership organs unfold as a political marketplace for a complex competition of interests, many of them external to the legal profession. This year, the biggest issue is arguably the role of ethno-tribal caucuses at the Nigerian Bar.
The road to this point was paved by a combination of ordinarily unrelated events. On 14 August 1991, Taslim Elias died. He was Nigeria’s Attorney-General at independence at a time when the position was deservedly prefixed with the honorific “honorable” (hence HAGF), later becoming Chief Justice of Nigeria. At his death, he was a judge of the International Court of Justice (ICJ). To replace Elias for the remainder of his ICJ tenure, Nigeria nominated Bola Ajibola, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN), who was then serving himself as HAGF.
That step opened up a vacancy for the designation of a new HAGF. To fill that vacancy, military ruler Ibrahim Babangida nominated Clement Akpamgbo SAN. At the time, Akpamgbo was in the middle of his tenure as the 15th president of the NBA. To succeed Akpamgbo as president and in keeping with its constitution, the NBA’s first Vice-President, Priscilla Kuye, succeeded Akpamgbo as president. She was the first woman in that position.
The next cycle of elections into the leadership of the association were scheduled to occur the following year in 1992. In August 1992, members duly convened in Port Harcourt, capital of Rivers State, for the elections but the conference was marked by significant tension. The leadership transition from Akpamgbo to Kuye had not been anticipated by many within the association, and the Port Harcourt gathering became a flashpoint for debates about the proper role of conventions in NBA governance.
At the heart of the 1992 election was a contest between two prominent candidates: Alao Aka-Bashorun SAN and Olisa Agbakoba SAN. Aka-Bashorun, a former president of the NBA, was seeking a return to office. Agbakoba, a human rights lawyer and activist, represented a younger generation of legal practitioners. The election was fiercely contested, with both candidates drawing support from different regional and ethnic blocs within the association.
The election ultimately resulted in a victory for Aka-Bashorun, but the process left deep scars. Accusations of manipulation and vote-buying were widespread, and the legitimacy of the outcome was questioned by many. The aftermath of the 1992 election saw the NBA fragmented along ethnic and regional lines, with caucuses emerging as powerful forces in the association’s internal politics.
These caucuses, often organized along ethno-tribal lines, began to assert themselves as de facto gatekeepers for leadership positions. They argued that their role was to ensure that the NBA’s leadership reflected the diversity of Nigeria’s legal profession. Critics, however, contended that these caucuses had transformed into instruments of exclusion, effectively vetoing candidates who did not belong to their ethnic or regional groups.
The situation came to a head in the 2020s, when the NBA’s internal governance mechanisms were tested by a series of controversial elections. In 2022, the association elected its 30th president, Olumide Akpata, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria. Akpata’s victory was hailed as a breakthrough for transparency and inclusivity, but it also exposed the deep divisions within the association. Akpata’s tenure was marked by efforts to reform the NBA’s electoral processes, including the introduction of electronic voting and the establishment of an independent electoral commission.
Despite these reforms, the role of ethno-tribal caucuses remained a contentious issue. In the run-up to the 2024 elections, several candidates were reportedly pressured to withdraw from the race by caucuses that claimed to represent the interests of specific ethnic groups. The NBA’s leadership was forced to intervene, issuing a statement condemning the use of “tribal vetoes” and reaffirming the association’s commitment to merit-based leadership selection.
The 2024 election ultimately saw the emergence of a new president, but the underlying tensions persisted. The question now facing the NBA is whether it can reconcile its founding principles of national unity and professional excellence with the reality of ethno-tribal politics. The association’s constitution, which was amended in 2015 to include provisions for regional representation, has been criticized for entrenching rather than mitigating these divisions.
As the NBA prepares for the 2026 elections, the stakes could not be higher. The association’s leadership has signaled its intention to revisit the issue of caucuses, with some members calling for a complete ban on ethno-tribal groupings within the NBA. Others argue that such a ban would be impractical and that the association should instead focus on strengthening its internal democratic processes.
The outcome of this debate will have far-reaching implications for the NBA’s future. If the association fails to address the role of ethno-tribal caucuses, it risks becoming a captive of narrow interests, undermining its credibility as a professional body. Conversely, if it succeeds in reforming its governance structures, it could emerge as a model for other professional associations in Nigeria and beyond.
The NBA’s journey from the Port Harcourt election of 1992 to the present day is a cautionary tale about the dangers of allowing conventions to harden into rigid rules. The association’s founders envisioned a bar that would transcend ethnic and regional divisions, but that vision has been tested by the realities of Nigerian politics. The question now is whether the NBA can reclaim its founding ideals and chart a path toward a more inclusive and professional future.
In the coming months, the NBA’s leadership will need to engage in a frank and open dialogue with its members about the role of caucuses. This dialogue must be grounded in the association’s constitutional principles and must prioritize the interests of the legal profession as a whole. The alternative is a continued erosion of trust and a deepening of the divisions that have plagued the NBA for decades.
The decision that the NBA makes in 2026 will shape its identity for generations to come. It is a decision that will test the association’s commitment to its own rules and its ability to adapt to changing circumstances. The future of an independent bar hangs in the balance.