Share This Post via WhatsApp

Peter Obi’s Election Claim and Nigeria’s Troubling Relationship With Evidence

Peter Obi, the presidential candidate of the Nigeria Democratic Congress, has once again asserted that he won the 2023 presidential election. During an interview with the BBC, he repeated this claim. When pressed on whether he possessed evidence to support it, he answered plainly: “There is no evidence.” He then added that not everything rests on evidence, insisting, “I won the election, and that is where I will end.”

As anticipated, the All Progressives Congress moved quickly to reject his position. Dele Alake, spokesman for the party’s Presidential Campaign Council, described Obi’s insistence as the conduct of a candidate who finished a distant third in the poll. According to Alake, maintaining such a claim without evidence and in contradiction of all official records reflects a deep and troubling disconnection from reality, as well as a disregard for facts and truth. While it is fair to acknowledge that Alake has reason to exaggerate for effect, it is equally necessary to point out that Obi’s actual placement in that election was not a “distant third” in any honest reading of the phrase.

Two Poles of Modern Life

Obi’s claim and Alake’s rebuttal speak to opposite ends of modern existence. Allegations, by their nature, demand proof. Modern legal systems rest on rational, authentic evidence rather than conjecture. A claim must be substantiated with tangible proof or informed opinion. This is precisely why certain conditions, including claims of spiritual affliction, can neither secure redress in court nor serve as a defence. Even when lawyers argue that a defendant was overtaken by irrational forces such as insanity, they must back the argument with evidence, and the threshold is not one that every unscrupulous defender can clear. It requires medical evaluations and expert opinion grounded in years of study and experience. The meaning of substantiating a claim, and the process of establishing facts and truths within the modern legal system, is therefore well understood.

Yet the fact that a claim cannot be proven in the ways modern society recognises as evidence does not automatically render it hollow. This is especially true in a society like Nigeria, where evidence, and the means of gathering it, can be corrupted in advance by habitual incompetence and a general lack of integrity. Nigeria is not a place where the veracity of evidence can be accepted uncritically, because there is a characteristic commitment to darkness and a fundamental absence of clarity. To make something clear is not merely to define it; it is to ensure transparency and accountability. That is not in the national character. The preference is to reign in darkness rather than serve with enlightenment.

This is why Alake’s reference to electoral victory being contained in “official records” invites a degree of amusement. The implication is that the process which produced those records is always neutral and can withstand scrutiny. Official records matter for all the reasons already stated, but it would be naive to pretend their contents cannot be used to substantiate a lie. Official records resemble history in one important respect: they are written by the victor. Even science, despite its claims of objectivity, can support falsehood or mischief. The mere appearance of something in formal records does not always make it trustworthy.

The Ibori Precedent

One of the clearest illustrations of the gap between official records and reality is the case of former Delta State governor James Ibori. In 2009, a Federal High Court in Asaba, Delta State, dismissed 170 counts of corruption and money laundering brought against him by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission. Just three years later, at Southwark Crown Court in London, the same Ibori pleaded guilty to 10 counts of fraud and money laundering involving tens of millions of pounds stolen from Delta State. He was sentenced to 13 years in prison. The same crime that Nigerian courts failed to see, whether because the prosecution was insufficiently diligent, the judge was legally blind, or both, was uncovered under the more probing gaze of British prosecutors.

Had the London case never happened, the gap between what Nigerian official records displayed and the truth would have handed Ibori all manner of moral and social grounds at the public’s expense. He would by now have walked around with his head held high, quite possibly bearing the title of “distinguished senator.” He would not only have claimed innocence of the crimes the EFCC accused him of, but would also have become a testament to his victory over his enemies. Had anyone called him a thief, he would have pointed out that official records said otherwise. Had an intrepid or reckless young person insinuated on social media that Ibori was a thief, he would have petitioned the police to make an arrest. The Nigerian police, ever-willing tools of oppression, would have crossed state lines to oblige him and have the person incarcerated indefinitely. All of that overreach would have been legal and appropriate, because official records had exonerated him.

The Tribunal, the Supreme Court, and Wike’s Admission

Obi challenged the results at the presidential election petition tribunal, alleging widespread irregularities. The tribunal dismissed his petition, holding that he failed to prove the electoral malpractice and other grounds on which he sought to overturn the results. In October, the Supreme Court panel unanimously threw out the appeals. The allegations of rigging, which were plainly visible in states such as Rivers, were dismissed as meritless.

Then came a curious twist. Just two weeks ago, Nyesom Wike, in a rare lucid moment of reprieve from what the article describes as his perpetual ogogoro stupor, practically admitted to election rigging during an interview on TVC. Speaking about the role he played in that election while serving as governor, his exact words were: “In Rivers, I said, ‘No, we have a problem here in Rivers. Obi will not win here. If he wins, it will send a signal…’ And I stopped it.” In court, such a confession is unlikely to meet the standards for admissible hard evidence, but it at least confirmed what was already suspected. Official records gave Tinubu victory; the unofficial record of his garrulous minister says otherwise. Add to that confession the fact that Tinubu appointed the INEC chairman who conducted that election as an ambassador, and the picture of how official records can conspire against reality becomes clearer.

Why the Judges Did Not See It

Why did the judges who adjudicated the election disputes not see it? Several explanations are possible. They may have been blinded by personal prejudice. The evidence submitted to them in court may have been tampered with. They may have concluded that the election was tense enough and not worth drawing out the tension further. Had they annulled parts of the election and forced a run-off, it would have exacerbated tensions that threatened to ignite the country. They may also have calculated that, even in a free and fair contest, Tinubu would have won anyway.

In Nigeria, because there is no objective way to verify the truth of a disputed election, historical patterns are used instead. A candidate is calculated to have won if they secure enough votes from four of the six geopolitical zones, and the supposed winner is then concluded. While patterns are useful for modelling, they can become self-fulfilling prophecies or part of electoral manipulation tactics. There is also the risk of becoming so wedded to how things ought to be that the ground shifting beneath one’s feet goes unnoticed. In 2023, some people were so convinced that Obi would finish a distant third because he lacked “structure,” which historical patterns told them was necessary for electoral victory, that the outcome confounded them. That is reason enough to be sceptical of predetermined patterns.

What Will Never Be Known

However the victory was determined, the whole truth will never be known. Tinubu will remain under a cloud of suspicion as a receiver of stolen goods. For a man with a shady reputation whose true identity, including family background, educational background, and career trajectory, cannot be found in official records, it is not even clear that such suspicion constitutes a source of shame.

Rate This Post / Article

Disclaimer: Every member is solely responsible for the content they publish on Nigerpress. Opinions, information, and statements expressed are not endorsed by Nigerpress.

Leave a Reply